The obvious text to mention here is:
Nudge: Improving Decisions About Health, Wealth, and Happiness.
by Richard H. Thaler and Cass R. Sunstein
Publisher: Yale University Press
ISBN: 9780300122237: Number of pages: 304
The notion of how to ‘nudge’ was brought to the fore by this 2008 book.
The primary concern I have with their text – written from the perspective of economists – arises from the assumption that you can help people to nudge some-one else. Shades of manipulation. This web site seeks to address only what you might do for yourself.
This book highlights how we make decisions about our lives but – too often – we choose poorly. I find this approach to ‘nudging’ values the ‘small defeat’ less than it might. To me, the ways in which we get things wrong can be an important step towards getting it right. The road to success is not a straight-as-a-die Motorway, but rather a scenic route with few clear indications of ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ steps en route.
Thaler and Sunstein are helpful in showing how humans are susceptible to various biases that can lead us to blunder. They say we can do things differently if we take humanness as a given and work with it – rather than against it. They invite us to enter an alternative world, They show that by knowing how people think, we can design and make choices that make get better results. Ther are easier ways we can choose what is best for ourselves and our families.
However, this view appears to neglect the fundamental issue: who designs the experiment, for what intention and how can we learn from the results.
Mistakes do not always make us poorer; the scenic route, with both small defeats and small victories littering the road, may teach us important lessons.
There is a web site addressing the larger political issues relating to nudging:
This web site highlights how ‘nudging’ arose from a wish to change others – it’s what politicians do – and it may well be an important motivator for people to go into politics! I want my own web site to provide an antidote to the paternalism emanating from the hidden persuaders. Let me know if I succeed or fail on the way, please!
I am asking you how you will design experiments based on the victories and defeats you choose to experience.